I asked squonk_npl this question:

Is Stranger Than Fiction a chick flick? I think so. Do you?

Here's my partial list of which movies I think qualify as male-driven chick flicks:

Big
Family Man
Keeping the Faith
About a Boy
Finding Neverland
King of Hearts
Men With Brooms
Milagro Beanfield War
Rock My World (Global Heresy)
Seabiscuit
Searching for Bobby Fischer
Unstrung Heroes